Effects of larval and adult crowding on fitness components in Drosophila populations adapted to larval crowding experienced under different combinations of food amount and egg number

Since the realization in the 1970s that simple discrete-time population growth models can show complex unstable dynamics of population size, many explanations were proposed for the evolution of enhanced population stability. The most plausible of these was density-dependent selection, suggested to favour greater stability due to r-K trade-offs. However, the first experiment aimed at testing this prediction revealed that Drosophila melanogaster populations adapted to larval crowding did not evolve greater constancy stability than their ancestral controls. A subsequent study showed that D. ananassae populations adapted to larval crowding had evolved greater constancy and persistence than ancestral controls. These D. ananassae populations had experienced chronic larval crowding in conditions of very low amounts of food, whereas the earlier studied D. melanogaster populations had experienced chronic larval crowding at fairly high food amounts. Further theoretical work also suggested that populations adapting to crowding could evolve greater stability even in the absence of r-K trade-offs. Most recently, studies in our laboratory showed that two sets of crowding adapted D. melanogaster populations, derived from a common ancestral lineage, which differed in the food amounts at which they experienced larval crowding, evolved different patterns of constancy and persistence stability. These two sets of populations also differed in the traits, e.g. larval feeding rate, that evolved as they became more competitive. Here, we examine the response of key fitness components to larval and adult densities in these two sets of populations, to see whether differences in their stability attributes can be explained by variation in how their life-histories respond to crowding at different life stages. Of all traits examined, only pre-adult survivorship responded differently to larval density across the two sets of populations. The populations that adapted to larval crowding at low food amounts showed reduced sensitivity of pre-adult survivorship to larval density, compared to those that adapted to larval crowding at high food amounts. We discuss our results in the context of different ways in which density-dependent selection may facilitate the evolution of greater constancy or persistence, depending on the ecological details of how crowding was experienced.