Plasma-derived cell-free DNA methylomes might not enable detection and discrimination of intracranial tumors
Abstract
Intracranial tumors are both hard to detect and diagnose, resulting in poor patient outcomes. For that reason, non-invasive methods enabling detection and discrimination of intracranial tumors have significant clinical potential. Recently Nassiri et al. propose plasma-derived cell-free DNA methylomes as such a method. Here I show that the results have been misinterpreted, and for many comparisons, no evidence supporting the conclusions are actually presented. While my analysis highlights the potential of plasma-derived cell-free DNA methylomes, the evidence provided by Nassiri et al. is simply currently insufficient.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papersReproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Noninvasive cancer detection by extracting and integrating multi-modal data from whole-methylome sequencing of plasma cell-free DNA
- Single-molecule systems for detection and monitoring of plasma circulating nucleosomes and oncoproteins in Diffuse Midline Glioma
- cfMIND: A read-level methylation framework for accurate non- invasive disease detection using cell-free DNA
- Sensitive tumor detection, accurate quantification, and cancer subtype classification using low-pass whole methylome sequencing of plasma DNA
Marta Paoli, Francesca Galardi, … Matteo Benelli·Genome MedicinePeer-reviewed·Feb 3, 2026
- Impedance-based assay for pan-cancer early and rapid detection of cell-free DNA
Tejal Dube, Puja Prasad, … Shalini Gupta·bioRxiv·May 10, 2024
- MetDecode: methylation-based deconvolution of cell-free DNA for non-invasive multi-cancer typing
Antoine Passemiers, Stefania Tuveri, … Joris Robert Vermeesch·BioinformaticsPeer-reviewed·Aug 22, 2024