Quantitative modeling reveals sources of variability in transcriptional activation assays

Abstract

Reporter cell assays, such as those used to detect estrogenic chemicals, can detect target chemicals at low concentrations and can be used to analyze chemical mixtures without a priori knowledge of the mixture components. However, the outputs of these assays are affected by biological variability, which complicates their interpretation. Here, we describe and demonstrate a workflow that is useful for determining potential sources of biological variability and optimizing the performance of cell-based assays. The workflow involves developing an appropriate mathematical model for a transcriptional activation assay, calibrating it with experimental data, and conducting sensitivity analysis to characterize individual components of the genetic circuit based on their effect on the reporter signal output. This workflow was tested using an estrogen receptor transcriptional activation assay. For this circuit, our analysis predicts that controlling estrogen response element number, promoter strength, and reporter signal degradation rates minimizes reporter output variability. We show that careful model development, calibration, and analysis can offer biologically relevant insights to minimize the variability of cell-based assays and improve genetic circuits for increased sensitivity and dynamic range.