Beyond efficacy: Persistence and off-target effects of three biological nitrification inhibitors in two contrasting agricultural soils

The use of nitrogen (N) fertilizers to meet global food demands is expected to continue rising. However, up to 70% of N applied to agricultural soils is lost through microbially mediated processes such as nitrification. Inhibiting nitrification is thus a key strategy to reduce N losses and improve fertilizer N use efficiency. Various plant-derived compounds, termed biological nitrification inhibitors (BNIs), have been shown to reduce accumulation of nitrification products, intermediates, and byproducts (nitrite, nitrate, nitric and nitrous oxides). However, the mechanisms by which BNIs affect nitrifiers, along with their specificity and persistence in soil are not well understood. Here, we evaluated the effects of three BNIs: methyl 3-(4-hydroxyphenyl) acrylate (MHPA), 6-methoxy-2(3H)-benzoxazolone (MBOA), and limonene, on ammonia-oxidizing, total microbial, and fungal communities in two soils with contrasting pH. Their persistence in each soil was also evaluated. Although ammonia-oxidizing archaea initially dominated nitrifier communities in both soils, their bacterial counterparts significantly increased after mineral N addition but also were more sensitive to BNI application. Limonene and the synthetic inhibitor DMPP stimulated ammonium immobilization, as total soil mineral N was significantly reduced. Limonene and MHPA had the strongest off-target effects, increasing the relative abundance of hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria and potential fungal pathogens, respectively. In contrast, MBOA inhibited nitrification with minimal off-target effects. Among the tested BNIs, MBOA was also the most persistent in the high-pH, high-nitrification-rate soil. Our results show that MBOA is a promising biological inhibitor and highlight the importance of understanding BNIs ecological effects to develop targeted and sustainable N management strategies.