bioRxivScientific Communication & Education
More than a token photo: humanizing scientists enhances student engagement
R. A. Costello, E. P. Driessen, M. K. Kjelvik, E. H. Schultheis, R. M. Youngblood, A. T. Zemenick, M. G. Weber, C. J. Ballen
Abstract
Highlighting scientists from historically excluded groups in educational materials increases student engagement in STEM. However, which specific elements of these educational materials maximize their impact remains untested, leaving educators guessing how to best highlight counter-stereotypical scientists in their classrooms. We tested the effects of including visual and humanizing descriptions of scientists featured in quantitative biology activities on over 3,700 students across 36 undergraduate institutions. We found that including humanizing information about counter-stereotypical scientists increased the extent to which students related to those scientists, which in turn translated to higher student engagement. Students who shared one or more excluded identity(s) with the featured scientists related most strongly. Our findings demonstrate the importance of humanizing counter-stereotypical scientists in classrooms, beyond simply adding a photo to increase representation.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- I Am A Scientist: Overcoming implicit bias in STEM through explicit representations of diversity in lectures
D. C. Henri, K. Coates, K. Hubbard·bioRxiv·Jun 23, 2022
- Can scientists fill the science journalism void? Online public engagement with science stories authored by scientists
Y. Barel-Ben David, E. S. Garty, A. Baram-Tsabari·bioRxiv·Sep 6, 2019
- High School Science Fair: Positive And Negative Outcomes
F. Grinnell, S. Dalley, J. Reisch·bioRxiv·Jan 30, 2020
- Inclusive pedagogy strategies to introduce high schoolers to systems biology
K. M. Watts, W. Richardson·bioRxiv·Mar 3, 2023
- High School Science Fair: Ethnicity Trends in Student Participation and Experience
F. Grinnell, S. Dalley, J. Reisch·bioRxiv·Dec 3, 2021
- Gender-based disparities and biases in science: observational study of a virtual conference
J. Zhang, R. Torchet, H. Julienne·bioRxiv·Mar 7, 2022