bioRxivAnimal Behavior & CognitionPreprint
Male mice prefer to live on their own
Jennifer R. DaviesiD, Megan G. JacksoniD, Justyna K. HinchcliffeiD, Michael MendliD, Emma S. J. RobinsoniD
Abstract
Around the world, guidance for the management of laboratory mice recommends social housing (1-3). However, fighting in male mice represents a major animal welfare and scientific issue. Despite the risks of stress and injury and associated welfare costs of incage aggression, we currently prioritise group housing. In this study we first validated a trans-species behavioural biomarker of affective state for mice using a chronic corticosterone model of depression. We next used the same methods to quantify affective state in male mice, group or singly housed in conventional versus individually ventilated cages (IVCs). The results revealed group housed male mice are in a negative affective state similar to that induced by chronic corticosterone treatment. IVC housing was also associated with a more negative affective state. These studies provide an objective assessment of the welfare costs of different housing conditions for male mice.
- organism: mouse
- assay: behavioral assay
- research focus: host-pathogen & immune response
- approach: experimental assay
In-depth summary
Claude Opus 5.5 · xhigh effort · 2 Nov 2026 · from the full text of version 1 (8 May 2025)
Reward learning bias, sucrose preference, and ultrasonic vocalisation assays show that singly housed male C57BL/6 mice in conventional cages exhibit a more positive affective state than group-housed mice.
Standard laboratory animal welfare guidelines recommend social housing for male mice despite frequent inter-male fighting and chronic social stress, and prior assessments have relied on indirect physiological or injury measures rather than objective affective-state biomarkers. Adapting a rat reward-learning cognitive bias assay to mice provides a direct behavioural measure of affective state to compare group versus single housing and conventional versus individually ventilated cages (IVCs).
Key results
ShownSingly housed male mice in conventional cages develop a stronger positive reward learning bias and higher sucrose preference than group-housed mice or mice in individually ventilated cages (IVCs).
Across 96 mice (single vs group of 3, conventional vs IVC cages), cage type (F(1,87)=6.491, p=0.0126) and grouping (F(1,87)=10, p=0.0022) affected session 10 reward bias; conventional singly housed mice had higher bias than conventional group-housed (t(88)=2.391, p=0.0189) and IVC singly housed mice (t(88)=2.356, p=0.0207), plus higher 2% sucrose preference (grouping F(1,84)=13.83, p=0.0004). · Male mice housed in groups and IVC caging…; Figure legends
ShownChronic corticosterone administration validates the Complex Cue T-Maze (CCTM) reward bias assay by abolishing the positive reward-induced learning bias seen in vehicle-treated control mice.
In 18 singly housed male C57BL/6 mice treated for 14 days with 25 ug/ml corticosterone-HBC or vehicle, controls showed a main effect of reward value (F=16.61, p=0.0036) across 10 sessions whereas corticosterone-treated mice did not (p>0.05) and had a significantly lower session 10 bias score (Mann-Whitney U(54, 24)=3, p=0.0216). · Development and validation of a reward bias…; Experiment 1: Validation of the complex cue T…; Corticosterone treatment and CCTM testing; Figure legends
ShownA replication cohort of singly housed male mice confirms that IVC housing impairs reward bias, reduces sucrose preference, and increases anxiety-like feeding latency compared to conventional caging.
In 36 singly housed male C57BL/6 mice (18 per group, 4 excluded), conventional caging produced a significant time*reward value interaction (F(9,135)=2.857, p=0.0041) and higher session 10 reward bias than IVC caging (t=2.076, p=0.0465), while IVC mice had lower 2% sucrose preference (t=2.112, p=0.0434) and longer latency to eat in the novelty suppressed feeding test (t=2.239, p=0.0333). · Male mice housed in groups and IVC caging…; Reward Learning Phase; Subjects; Figure legends
SuggestedSingly housed male mice emit more ultrasonic vocalisations (USVs) over time than group-housed mice.
In a 42-day home-cage recording study (n=3 single-housed cages vs n=3 cages of 3 mice, normalized by dividing group calls by 3), USV call rates showed a main effect of time (F(1.389,5.556)=14.52, p=0.0081), a time x housing interaction (F(35,140)=6.356, p<0.0001), and higher total calls in singly housed mice (Mann-Whitney U=0, p<=0.05). · Effects of group vs single housing on ultrasonic…; Subjects; USVs recording and analysis; Figure legends
Methods, data and reproducibility
Developed and validated the Complex Cue T-Maze (CCTM) reward bias assay (3D-printed textured floors paired with 10 ul of 5% vs 2% condensed milk over 10 sessions of 20 trials) using a 14-day chronic corticosterone model. Evaluated male C57BL/6 mice housed singly or in groups of 3 in conventional or IVC cages using the CCTM, 2% sucrose preference test, novelty suppressed feeding test, and 42-day USV recordings.
- Experiment 1: Chronic corticosterone (25 ug/ml in drinking water) vs vehicle validation in singly housed male C57BL/6 mice (8 weeks old) · mouse · n = 18 mice (n=9 per group; 3 per group missing session 10)
- Housing and caging experiment in male C57BL/6 mice (6 weeks old) across 4 conditions (single vs group of 3, conventional vs IVC cages) · mouse · n = 96 mice (8 replicates of n=12; 3 excluded for fighting)
- Replication cohort comparing single housing in conventional vs IVC cages in male C57BL/6 mice · mouse · n = 36 mice (18 per group; 4 excluded for non-learning)
- Home-cage ultrasonic vocalisation (USV) 42-day recording cohort in male C57BL/6JOlaHsd mice (6-12 weeks old) · mouse · n = 12 mice across 6 cages (3 single cages, 3 cages of 3 mice)
- Methods & tools
- Complex Cue T-Maze (CCTM), Avisoft RECORDER USGH (v4.4), DeepSqueak (v3.6.2), GraphPad Prism (v10.0.03)
- Reagents & environment
- Avisoft RECORDER USGH v4.4, DeepSqueak v3.6.2, GraphPad Prism v10.0.03.
- Reproducibility gaps
- No public repository links or accession numbers are provided for raw behavioural data or ultrasonic vocalisation audio recordings.
Limitations (3)
- Whether the negative affective impact of IVC caging stems from reduced olfactory/auditory social cues or from environmental factors such as higher ventilation rates and temperature remains undetermined. · stated by the authors
- The ultrasonic vocalisation experiment was an exploratory study with a small sample size of 3 cages per housing group, and group-housed call counts were estimated by dividing total cage calls by 3 rather than attributing calls to individual mice. · noted in this summary
- All experiments were conducted exclusively in young adult male C57BL/6 (and C57BL/6JOlaHsd) mice from a single supplier, so generalisability to other mouse strains or ages is not tested here. · noted in this summary
Read this if you design or manage rodent behavioural and preclinical studies and want quantitative affective-state evidence on how group versus single housing and IVC caging affect male mice.
- Citations
- 5
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Environmental enrichment delays the development of stereotypic behavior and reduces variability in behavioral experiments using California mice (Peromyscus californicus).
V. Minie, S. Ramos-Maciel, … N. Duque-Wilckens·bioRxiv·Jan 5, 2021
- Female behavior drives the formation of distinct social structures in C57BL/6J versus wild-derived outbred mice in field enclosures
C. C. Vogt, M. N. Zipple, … M. J. Sheehan·bioRxiv·Apr 19, 2022
- Presence of a home cage running wheel, but not wheel running per se, decreases social motivation in adult C57BL/6J female mice
Patryk Ziobro, Cassidy A. Malone, … Katherine Tschida·PLoS ONEPeer-reviewed·Jul 28, 2026
- Social hierarchy position in female mice is associated with plasma corticosterone levels and hypothalamic gene expression
C. M. Williamson, W. Lee, … J. P. Curley·bioRxiv·Apr 4, 2019
- Induction of territorial behavior and dominance hierarchies in laboratory mice
Dorian Battivelli, Lucas Boldrini, … Cornelius Thilo Gross·Scientific ReportsPeer-reviewed·Nov 19, 2024
- Stress Evaluation of Various Breeding Environments in Mouse
G. Lee, H.-Y. Choi, … K. Kim·bioRxiv·Aug 27, 2021