Unveiling the mechanisms of black phosphorus nanosheets-induced viable but non-culturable state in Bacillus tropicus

The release of black phosphorus (BP) nanosheets has raised concerns regarding potential ecological risks. Previous studies have confirmed their toxicity to bacteria, but discrepancies were observed between results obtained from the growth curve and colony forming unit (CFU) methods, indicating the possibility of bacterial cells entering a viable but non-culturable (VBNC) state induced by BP nanosheets. To accurately assess the risks, it is crucial to understand the underlying mechanisms. In this study, we investigated the effect of BP nanosheets on Bacillus tropicus, a gram-positive bacterium, using transcriptome sequencing and biological assays. Our findings revealed that BP nanosheets caused minimal cell death but predominately induced the VBNC state in most cells. At the transcriptional level, we observed significant down-regulation of pathways associated with cellular metabolism and respiratory chain in response to BP nanosheet treatment. Bacterial cells in the VBNC state exhibited depressed respiration to maintain basal cellular activity. Additionally, the reduced cellular respiration and metabolic activity were associated with a decrease in antibiotic susceptibility of the bacteria. These results provide new insights into the antibacterial mechanisms of BP nanosheets and emphasize the necessity of employing appropriate approaches, beyond the traditional CFU method, to assess the bacterial toxicity of nanomaterials. Environmental implicationBacteria play a crucial role as indicators in ecological risk assessment. Although numerous studies have highlighted the exceptional antibacterial properties of black phosphorus (BP) nanosheets, the unique viable but non-culturable (VBNC) state of bacteria is often overlooked when evaluating the ecological risks of nanomaterial, including BP nanosheets. In our study, we found that BP nanosheets can induce Bacillus tropicus into a VBNC state by suppressing cellular metabolism- and respiratory chain-related pathways, shedding light on their ecological risk assessment implications. This finding underscores the importance of utilizing appropriate approaches in evaluating the bacterial toxicity of nanomaterials.