The interplay of climate change, urbanization, and species traits shapes European butterfly population trends

Abstract

Species populations naturally fluctuate, yet long-term trend analysis can reveal patterns of success, decline, or stability under global change pressures. While responses to climate change are well-documented, its synergy with another major global driver, urbanization, remains understudied. Here, we analyzed long-term monitoring data from over 8,400 populations of 145 butterfly species across Europe, representing a high diversity of species traits, to assess population trends in response to climate change and urbanization. We examined how population responses vary between urban and rural contexts, providing insights into the influence of site-specific conditions. Climate warming was associated with population declines, which were more pronounced in urban areas. The effect of precipitation varied between environments: increases in precipitation generally benefited populations in rural areas but had detrimental effects in urban ones. Aridity consistently drove population declines across environments, with slightly stronger effects in urban areas. Species with colder climatic niches declined the most in response to warming, increased aridity, and reduced precipitation, while trophic specialists were particularly vulnerable to aridity and precipitation changes in urban environments. Although increasing urbanization did not explain overall population trends, its effects became evident when considering species traits, with certain traits being more vulnerable to urbanization. Specifically, species with narrow climatic niches declined the most in response to urbanization in rural areas, while those and larger body sizes decline the most in urban environments. Our findings highlight the complex interplay between environmental change, landscape context, and species traits in shaping biodiversity outcomes. Importantly, our results suggest that urbanization generally amplifies the impact of climate change on insect population trends.