Information-Content-Informed Kendall-tau Correlation Methodology: Interpreting Missing Values in Metabolomics as Potentially Useful Information

BackgroundAlmost all correlation measures currently available are unable to directly handle missing values. Typically, missing values are either ignored completely by removing them or are imputed and used in the calculation of the correlation coefficient. In either case, the correlation value will be impacted based on a perspective that the missing data represents no useful information. However, missing values occur in real data sets for a variety of reasons. In metabolomics data sets, a major reason for missing values is that a specific measurable phenomenon falls below the detection limits of the analytical instrumentation (left-censored values). These missing data are not missing at random, but represent potentially useful information by virtue of their "missingness" at one end of the data distribution. MethodsTo include this information due to left-censorsed missingness, we propose the information-content-informed Kendall-tau (ICI-Kt) methodology. We developed a statistical test and then show that most missing values in metabolomics datasets are the result of left-censorship. Next, we show how left-censored missing values can be included within the definition of the Kendall-tau correlation coefficient, and how that inclusion leads to an interpretation of information being added to the correlation. We also implement calculations for additional measures of theoretical maxima and pairwise completeness that add further layers of information interpretation in the methodology. ResultsUsing both simulated and over 700 experimental data sets from The Metabolomics Workbench, we demonstrate that the ICI-Kt methodology allows for the inclusion of left-censored missing data values as interpretable information, enabling both improved determination of outlier samples and improved feature-feature network construction. ConclusionsWe provide explicitly parallel implementations in both R and Python that allow fast calculations of all the variables used when applying the ICI-Kt methodology on large numbers of samples. The ICI-Kt methods are available as an R package and Python module on GitHub at https://github.com/moseleyBioinformaticsLab/ICIKendallTau and https://github.com/moseleyBioinformaticsLab/icikt, respectively.