Cartilage canals in sharks and rays show that blood vessels can exist in mature cartilage without triggering endochondral bone formation

Abstract

Although cartilage in tetrapod skeletons is typically said to lack blood vessels, this is only true for adult cartilage. In young bird and mammal cartilage, a dense network of vasculature-containing tunnels --cartilage canals-- perforate the growing skeleton, helping nourish the cartilage and develop the ossification centers that will later form the skeletons epiphyseal bone. As the canals and their rich vascular network typically recede as animals age, the healthy cartilage of adult animals is typically known to be avascular. Here, however, we use a range of tissue characterization and visualization techniques --including light/electron microscopy and microCT-- to show that the skeletons of rays and sharks (elasmobranch fishes) not only possess cartilage canals, but that these structures persist in the adult skeleton. The morphology and tissue composition of elasmobranch cartilage canals argues homology with mammalian cartilage canals and an ancient invasion of the vascular system into cartilage. However, the anatomical location of canals --extending away from mineralized tissue not toward it-- and the lack of endochondral ossification in ray and shark cartilage suggest that cartilage canals developed early in vertebrates as a transport system for nutrients and mesenchymal cells into the growing skeleton. We describe distinctive features and variation in elasmobranch cartilage canals, discuss their possible roles and their potential for tissue mineralization, and the biomedical implications for their presence in a clade of animals with continuously growing cartilaginous skeletons.