Background color matching influences sexual behavior, growth, and mortality rate in an African cichlid fish

Phenotypic plasticity allows organisms to adapt to changing environments within their lifetimes. The cost of plastic adaptations may constrain the persistence of plasticity over evolutionary time. One potential cost is the possibility that phenotypic adjustment to specific environments can cause correlated responses that are not necessarily adaptive. Males in the African cichlid Astatotilapia burtoni are blue or yellow, and males are able adjust their body coloration to the color of the background, presumably to increase crypsis. To test whether background color influences fitness-related traits, we raised mix-sex groups of juvenile A. burtoni to adulthood in yellow or blue tanks. We found that fish in blue tanks were darker and more bluish, whereas fish reared in yellow tanks were paler and more yellow in body coloration. Males, but not females, from blue tanks showed earlier sexual maturation than those held in yellow tanks. However, across the duration of the experiment, there was a higher frequency of females mouthbrooding in groups housed in yellow tanks than those that were housed in blue tanks. In addition, fish in blue tanks exhibited reduced growth rate but higher survivorship relative to their yellow-reared counterparts. Our data suggests that background color affects important fitness-related traits in a color polymorphic cichlid, which may influence the evolution of phenotypic plasticity.