Subtle variations in a client protein determine bacterial Hsp90 dependence

Chaperones ensure protein homeostasis and are conserved across species. The ATP-dependent chaperone Hsp90 is present from bacteria to eukaryotes, where it stabilizes and activates a wide range of substrate proteins called clients. However, what determines whether a protein depends on Hsp90 remains an open question. Here, we focused on the bacterial chaperone Hsp90 and its obligate client TilS (referred to as TilSSo) in the bacterium Shewanella oneidensis. Although Hsp90 is indispensable in S. oneidensis under heat stress by protecting the essential protein TilSSo from degradation by the protease HslUV, Hsp90 is dispensable in Escherichia coli, suggesting that E. coli TilS (TilSEc) is Hsp90 independent. We therefore compared the TilS orthologs with respect to in vitro stability, in vivo degradation, and interaction with Hsp90 to identify the determinants of the Hsp90 dependence. We found that in contrast to TilSSo, TilSEc was more stable, was not degraded by protease in the absence of Hsp90, and did not interact with Hsp90, indicating that TilSEc is not a client of Hsp90. Chimeras between TilSSo and TilSEc as well as directed mutagenesis revealed a region of TilSSo that is key for protease degradation and Hsp90 protection. Consistent with these results, the growth of S. oneidensis producing TilSEc was no longer dependent on Hsp90 under heat stress. Conversely, Hsp90 became essential for the growth of E. coli that produced TilSSo instead of TilSEc. Taken together, these results provide new insights into the mechanism of client protection by Hsp90 and the interplay between chaperones and proteases.