F1000ResearchMolecular BiologyPeer-reviewed journal article
Alternative miRNAs: Human Sequences Misidentified As Plant miRNAs In Plant Studies And In Human Plasma
Abstract
A recent study reported that \"Plant miRNAs found in human circulating system provide evidences of cross kingdom RNAi\" 1. Analysis of two human blood plasma sequencing datasets was said to provide evidence for uptake of plant miRNAs into human plasma. The results were also purportedly inconsistent with contamination 1. However, a review of these data suggests that they do not support dietary xenomiR uptake, but instead confirm previous findings that detection of rare plant miRNAs in mammalian sequencing datasets is artifactual. Only one putative plant miRNA (\"peu-MIR2910) in this study mapped consistently above background, and this sequence is found in a human rRNA. Several other rarer but consistently mapped plant miRNAs also have 100% or near 100% matches to human transcripts or genomic sequences, and some do not map to plant genomes at all. These misidentified \"alternative miRNAs\"--including MIR2910 and MIR2911--emphasize the need for rigorous filtering strategies when assessing possible xenomiRNAs.
- organism: human
- organism: plant (other)
- assay: bulk RNA-seq
- research focus: differential expression
- research focus: benchmarking
- research focus: database / resource
- approach: statistical model
- approach: experimental assay
- Citations
- 46
- FWCI
- 1.67
- Field percentile
- top 17%
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Predict plant-derived xenomiRs from plant miRNA sequences using random forest and one-dimensional convolutional neural network models
Qi Zhao, Qian Mao, … Xiaoya Fan·BMC GenomicsPeer-reviewed·Nov 26, 2018
- Identification of plant-derived microRNAs in human kidney
Xi Chen, Xishao Xie, … Longjiang Fan·bioRxiv·Oct 25, 2022
- miR-21-5p and miR-30a-5p are identical in human and bovine, have similar isomiR distribution, and cannot be used to identify xenomiR uptake from cow milk
Bastian Fromm, Juan Pablo Tosar, … Kenneth Whitaker Witwer·Journal of NutritionPeer-reviewed·Jun 19, 2018
- RPRH: a web-based tool for the inference of potential roles of plant microRNAs in human body
Yuanxu Gao, Chunmei Cui, … Qinghua Cui·bioRxiv·Jun 11, 2020
- miRCurator: A rapid curation and analysis tool for plantmicroRNA studies
Bihter Avşar, Danial Esmaeili Aliabadi·bioRxiv·Jan 10, 2023
- Revisiting criteria for plant miRNA annotation in the era of big data
M. J. Axtell, B. C. Meyers·bioRxiv·Dec 27, 2017