Recovery of small plasmid sequences via Oxford Nanopore sequencing

Abstract

Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) sequencing platforms currently offer two approaches to whole-genome native-DNA library preparation: ligation and rapid. In this study, we compared these two approaches for bacterial whole-genome sequencing, with a specific aim of assessing their ability to recover small plasmid sequences. To do so, we sequenced DNA from seven plasmid-rich bacterial isolates in three different ways: ONT ligation, ONT rapid and Illumina. Using the Illumina read depths to approximate true plasmid abundance, we found that small plasmids (<20 kbp) were underrepresented in ONT ligation read sets (by a mean factor of [~]4) but were not underrepresented in ONT rapid read sets. This effect correlated with plasmid size, with the smallest plasmids being the most underrepresented in ONT ligation read sets. We also found lower rates of chimeric reads in the rapid read sets relative to ligation read sets. These results show that when small plasmid recovery is important, ONT rapid library preparations are preferable to ligation-based protocols. Impact statementResearchers who use Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) platforms to sequence bacterial genomes can currently choose from two library preparation methods. The first is a ligation-based approach, which uses ligase to attach sequencing adapters to the ends of DNA molecules. The second is a rapid approach, which uses a transposase enzyme to cleave DNA and attach adapters in a single step. There are advantages to each preparation, for example ligation can produce better yields but rapid is a simpler procedure. Our study reveals another advantage of rapid preparations: they are more effective at sequencing small plasmids. We show that sequencing of ligation-based libraries yields fewer reads derived from small plasmids, making such plasmids harder to detect in bacterial genomes. Since small plasmids can contain clinically relevant genes, including antimicrobial resistance (AMR) or virulence determinants, their exclusion could lead to unreliable conclusions that have serious consequences for AMR surveillance and prediction. We therefore recommend that researchers performing ONT-only sequencing of bacterial genomes should consider using rapid preparations whenever small plasmid recovery is important. Data summarySupplementary figures, tables, data and code can be found at: github.com/rrwick/Small-plasmid-Nanopore