Media Matters: Phenol Red and Fetal Bovine Serum Estrogen in Traditional Cell Culture Media Influence Human Mesenchymal Stromal Cell (hMSC) Processes and Differentiation in a Sex-Biased Manner

Abstract

Estrogens are global regulators of cellular signaling pathways, impacting fundamental processes and phenotypes that are essential for tissue remodeling and homeostasis. Traditional cell culture media contains estrogen-mimetic compounds, including phenol red and endogenous estrogen in fetal bovine serum (FBS). However, the potential of these compounds to bias in vitro studies, particularly when considering sex as a biological variable, remains unclear. This gap in understanding critically impacts the culture of human mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSCs), whose basic functions and differentiation potential, central to cell therapy and tissue engineering, are sensitive to perturbations in the culture conditions. Despite this, the effect of estrogens from cell culture media on male and female hMSCs is not currently considered in cell processing for clinical trials. As such, a baseline understanding of these estrogen-mimetic media influences on hMSCs is critical for clinical efficacy and adequate study design in research. To this end, we investigated the effects of phenol red and fetal bovine serum on the proliferation, metabolism, senescence, and differentiation capacity of male and female hMSCs. Phenol red, FBS, donor sex, and 17{beta}-estradiol (E2) supplementation all had significant impacts on hMSC health and differentiation potential in culture. Notably, dosing with estrogen at the levels found in FBS did not recover most of the hMSC metrics tested. The only outcomes that were not significantly different based on donor sex were senescence and mRNA transcripts for RUNX2 and PPARG, transcriptional regulators for osteogenesis and adipogenesis. Overall, these findings reveal the sex-biased effects of estrogen and estrogen-mimetic compounds in traditional culture media, underscoring a current gap in considering sex as a biological variable in cell therapy and tissue engineering research and manufacturing.