Paresthesia during spinal cord stimulation depends on synchrony of dorsal column axon activation

Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) reduces chronic pain. Conventional (40-60 Hz) SCS engages spinal inhibitory mechanisms by activating low-threshold mechanoreceptive afferents with axons in the dorsal columns (DCs). But activating DC axons typically causes a buzzing sensation (paresthesia) that can be uncomfortable. Kilohertz-frequency (1-10 kHz) SCS produces analgesia without paresthesia and is thought, therefore, not to activate DC axons, leaving its mechanism unclear. Here we show in rats that kilohertz-frequency SCS activates DC axons but causes them to spike less synchronously than conventional SCS. Spikes desynchronize because axons entrain irregularly when stimulated at intervals shorter than their refractory period, a phenomenon we call overdrive desynchronization. Effects of overdrive desynchronization on evoked compound action potentials were verified in simulations, rats, pigs, and a chronic pain patient. Whereas synchronous spiking in DC axons is necessary for paresthesia, asynchronous spiking is sufficient to produce analgesia. Asynchronous activation of DC axons thus produces paresthesia-free analgesia.