Evidence for compensatory evolution within pleiotropic regulatory elements

Pleiotropy, measured as expression breadth across tissues, is one of the best predictors for protein sequence and expression conservation. In this study, we investigated its effect on the evolution of cis-regulatory elements (CREs). To this end, we carefully reanalyzed the Epigenomics Roadmap data for nine fetal tissues, assigning a measure of pleiotropic degree to nearly half a million CREs. To assess the functional conservation of CREs, we generated ATAC-seq and RNA-seq data from humans and macaques. We found that more pleiotropic CREs exhibit greater conservation in accessibility, and the mRNA expression levels of the associated genes are more conserved. This trend of higher conservation for higher degrees of pleiotropy persists when analyzing the transcription factor binding repertoire. In contrast, simple DNA sequence conservation of orthologous sites between species tends to be even lower for pleiotropic CREs than for species-specific CREs. Combining various lines of evidence, we suggest that the lack of sequence conservation for functionally conserved pleiotropic elements is due to compensatory evolution within these large pleiotropic CREs. Furthermore, for less pleiotropic CREs, we find an indication of compensation across CREs. This suggests that pleiotropy is also a good predictor for the functional conservation of CREs, but this is not reflected in the sequence conservation for pleiotropic CREs.