Comparative evaluation of reference genomes and cell-type annotation frameworks for single-nucleus transcriptomic analysis in apple
Sun HuiD, Yiqi Liu, Yujie ZhaoiD, Bo LiiD, Yawen SheniD, Yoshiharu MimataiD, Kunxi ZhangiD, Pengbo HaoiD, Jiangli ShiiD, Zhiwei LuoiD, Wenxiu YeiD, Xianbo ZhengiD, Jian JiaoiD
Abstract
Single-nucleus RNA sequencing (snRNA-seq) provides a powerful tool to profile cell-type-specific transcriptional programs in woody fruit trees. Yet its application in Malus domestica has been limited by heterogeneous reference genomes and the lack of validated marker genes. Here, we first established a comprehensive set of marker genes corresponding to 29 plant cell types and identified their orthologs in apple. Using these resources, we systematically evaluated six publicly available apple genome assemblies as references for snRNA-seq analysis. Our results demonstrate that reference genome selection has a major impact on mapping performance and downstream cell type annotation, with the GDDH13 assembly consistently producing the highest transcript counts per nucleus and the greatest number of identifiable transcriptional clusters (15 clusters representing 11 distinct cell types across 35,557 high-quality nuclei). To achieve robust cell type annotation, we integrated classical marker gene-based annotation with two cross-species computational frameworks -- Orthologous Marker Gene Groups (OMGs) and XSpeciesSpanner. These three approaches enabled confident identification of 11 major cell types in apple seedlings and provided cross-validation for ambiguous or previously unannotated clusters. Pseudotime analysis reconstructed the developmental trajectories of both procambial and stomatal lineages, revealing their progressive transcriptional transitions and enabling the delineation of key molecular programs underlying vascular differentiation and early guard-cell formation. Together, this work provides a reference-quality single-nucleus transcriptomic atlas for apple and underlined the critical impact of genome choice and multi-method cell-type annotation on single-cell studies in non-model crops.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 1
- FWCI
- 2.09
- Field percentile
- top 21%
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Single-nucleus RNA-seq resolves spatiotemporal developmental trajectories in the tomato shoot apex
- Single-nuclei RNA-sequencing of plant tissues
Daniele Y. Sunaga-Franze, José M. Muiño, … Sascha Sauer·bioRxiv·Nov 14, 2020
- A Comprehensive Epidermal Map from a Poplar Single-Cell Shoot Atlas Reveals New Trichome-Specific Genes
Anita Giabardo, Joshua C. Wood, … C. Robin Buell·bioRxiv·Jul 3, 2026
- A robust method of nuclei isolation for single-cell RNA sequencing of solid tissues from the plant genus Populus
D. Conde, P. M. Triozzi, … M. Kirst·bioRxiv·Feb 11, 2021
- A Single-Nucleus Atlas of Seed-to-Seed Development in Arabidopsis
T. A. Lee, T. Nobori, … J. R. Ecker·bioRxiv·Mar 23, 2023
- Cross-species single-cell annotation with orthologous marker gene groups
Tran N. Chau, Prakash Raj Timilsena, … Song Li·Nature CommunicationsPeer-reviewed·Jan 2, 2025