Expanding the Genome in a Bottle Truth Set: Detection and Validation of Novel Low-frequency Variants Using High-accuracy NanoSeq
Yang ZhangiD, Hsu Chao, Muchun NiuiD, Christopher M Grochowski, Kavya KottapalliiD, Sravya V Bhamidipati, Donna Marie MuznyiD, Richard A. GibbsiD, Chenghang Chuck ZongiD, Harsha Vardhan Doddapaneni
Abstract
HighlightsO_LINanoSeq-MBN achieves near-genome, Poisson-like coverage with minimal trinucleotide bias. C_LIO_LIExpands the GIAB truth set by up to 160k de novo variants. C_LIO_LIAdds a somatic layer to GIAB, enabling benchmarking and calibration of rare variants. C_LIO_LIHigh-CADD exonic and splice variants highlight value for surveillance and clinical triage. C_LI Somatic mutations record tissue molecular history and inform risk, prognosis, and therapy, yet their variant allele fractions often fall below the reliable detection limit of conventional short-read sequencing. In contrast, duplex sequencing technology featured by NanoSeq applies the principle of single molecule detection and thereby overcomes the limitation. However, the original NanoSeq protocol relies on the restriction enzyme-based genome fragmentation, which constrained its genome coverage to 30-40%. To enable whole-genome discovery with duplex-level fidelity, we pursued two complementary approaches to optimize the NanoSeq protocol: (i) a restriction-enzyme strategy densifies accessible sites using orthogonal 4-bp cutters; and (ii) a workflow using sonication followed by mung bean nuclease with T4 polynucleotide kinase, Klenow fragment and dATP/ddBTP mixture (NanoSeq-MBN) to blunt and repair/A-tailing DNA, while minimizing repair artifacts. We systematically benchmarked their performance using Genome in a Bottle (GIAB) gold-standard sample mixtures. As a result, NanoSeq-MBN achieved near genome-wide, Poissonlike coverage with minimal trinucleotide-context bias and ultra-high accuracy. Beyond variants already present in the GIAB truth set, NanoSeq-MBN identified approximately 120,000-160,000 de novo mutations per sample missing in the truth set, Notably, over 98% had orthogonal support in reanalyzed GIAB bulk Illumina HiSeq libraries. These novel variants extended GIAB from germline benchmarking to rare-variant discovery and calibration of subclonal detection. Functional annotation revealed enrichment of high Combined Annotation Dependent Depletion (CADD) scores mutations in exonic and splice-related regions. Variants intersecting ClinVar entries and OMIM genes highlighted potential for surveillance and clinical triage. Collectively, these results add a somatic layer to GIAB, enabling calibration of burdens and mutational signatures in lymphoblastoid lines and provide reference material for rare-variant assays. The NanoSeq-MBN workflow offers a path to whole-genome, high-fidelity discovery of ultra-rare somatic variation with relevance to clinical assay validation.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 0
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Deep Sequencing of 10,000 Human Genomes
Amalio Telenti, Levi T Pierce, … J. Craig Venter·Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesPeer-reviewed·Oct 4, 2016
- NanoVar: Accurate Characterization of Patients’ Genomic Structural Variants Using Low-Depth Nanopore Sequencing
Cheng Yong Tham, Roberto Tirado-Magallanes, … Touati Benoukraf·Genome biologyPeer-reviewed·Mar 3, 2020
- Optimised multiplex amplicon sequencing for mutation identification using the MinION nanopore sequencer
Whitney Whitford, Victoria Hawkins, … Jessie C. Jacobsen·Scientific ReportsPeer-reviewed·May 20, 2022
- The Genome In A Bottle HG002 assembly-based variant benchmark set enables comprehensive benchmarking of small and structural variants.
N. D. Olson, N. Dwarshuis, … Lan·bioRxiv·Oct 1, 2026
- Detecting and Quantitating Low Fraction DNA Variants with Low-Depth Sequencing
P. Song, S. X. Chen, … D. Y. Zhang·bioRxiv·Apr 26, 2020
- Low-coverage genome sequencing for the detection of clinically relevant copy-number and mtDNA variants
Sander Pajusalu, Mikk Tooming, … Katrin Õunap·medRxiv·Sep 20, 2022