Gene expression is stable despite widespread cis and trans regulatory divergence in Saccharomyces yeasts

Abstract

Regulatory evolution can alter phenotypes, but cis- and trans-regulatory mechanisms may also diverge extensively while total transcript abundance remains stable. Comparisons of parental expression with allele-specific expression in F1 hybrids provide a framework for separating cis- and trans-regulatory effects because both parental alleles are measured in a shared trans-regulatory environment. Here, we analyzed RNA sequencing data from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Saccharomyces paradoxus, and their F1 hybrid. Regulatory divergence was widespread, with 61.3% of tested orthologs showing significant divergence in at least one cis or trans component. However, hybrid expression remained largely conserved, with 81.6% of genes not significantly different from either parent. Compensatory cis-trans divergence predominated over reinforcing divergence, consistent with widespread buffering of transcript abundance. To connect genome-wide patterns to mechanism, we analyzed the strongly cis-diverged locus LYS2 and found species differences in promoter architecture, including an S. cerevisiae-specific AT-rich insertion, altered spacing among candidate regulatory features, and a promoter-proximal TATA-like element unique to S. cerevisiae. Sequence-based nucleosome prediction suggests that these differences create a broader promoter-proximal nucleosome-depleted region in S. cerevisiae than in S. paradoxus. We also quantified allele-resolved intron retention and found that splicing was broadly conserved, with only rare locus-specific hybrid-associated shifts. Together, these results show that regulatory divergence is widespread but often buffered in the hybrid, whereas post-transcriptional divergence is comparatively limited.