Journal of InfectionGenetic & Genomic MedicinePeer-reviewed journal article
Translating metagenomics into clinical practice of complex paediatric neurological presentations
Justin PenneriD, Jane K. HasselliD, Julianne Rose BrowniD, Kshitij MankadiD, Nathaniel StoreyiD, Laura AtkinsoniD, Nisha Ranganathan, Alexander LennoniD, Jack C. D. LeeiD, Dimitrios ChampsasiD, Angelika Kopec, Divya ShahiD, Cristina VenturiniiD, Garth L. J. DixoniD, Surjo Kiran De, James HatcheriD, Kathryn HarrisiD, Kristian AquilinaiD, Maaike KustersiD, Karyn L. Moshal, Delane V. Shingadia, Austen J. J. WorthiD, Giovanna LucchiniiD, Ashirwad MerveiD, Thomas S. JacquesiD, , Sofia MorfopoulouiD
Abstract
BackgroundAtypical or complex paediatric neurological presentations are common clinical conundrums and often remain undiagnosed despite extensive investigations. This is particularly pronounced in immunocompromised patients. Here we show that clinical metagenomics (CMg) is a valuable adjunct diagnostic tool to be used by neuro-infection multidisciplinary teams (MDTs). MethodsWe included patients referred to the Great Ormond Street Hospital neuro-infection MDT in whom diagnostic uncertainty remained, despite a standardised comprehensive set of investigations, and who were referred for untargeted CMg on brain tissue and/or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). In a retrospective review, two clinicians independently assessed whether CMg in conjunction with the MDT resulted in a change of management. Findings60 undiagnosed patients met the inclusion criteria. We detected the causative pathogen by CMg in 14/60 (23%), with 12/36 patients known to be immunocompromised. CMg results, even when negative, informed patient care, resulting in changes in clinical management in 42/57 (74%). Six patients had unexpected findings of pathogens not identified on prior samples. In four patients, the pathogen was found solely in the brain biopsy and was absent from all other specimens, including CSF. InterpretationCMg is particularly useful when conventional diagnostic techniques for meningoencephalitis are exhausted and proved to be an important diagnostic tool for immunocompromised patients. CMg provided increased reassurance against an infective aetiology prior to recommending immunosuppressive or immunomodulatory treatment. Specialised MDTs should advocate for early brain biopsies and routine CMg in an experienced laboratory for undiagnosed complex neurological cases affecting immunocompromised patients.
- organism: human
- assay: metagenomics
- research focus: differential expression
- approach: experimental assay
- Citations
- 19
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- A Metagenomics - Based Diagnostic Approach for Central Nervous System Infections in Hospital Acute Care Setting
M. R. Hasan, S. Sundararaju, … P. Tilley·bioRxiv·Aug 31, 2019
- Metagenomics for chronic meningitis: clarifying interpretation and diagnosis
M. R. Wilson, B. D. O'Donovan, … J. L. DeRisi·bioRxiv·Nov 7, 2017
- Metagenomic Next-generation Sequencing of Cerebrospinal Fluid for the Diagnosis of Central Nervous System Infections: A Multicentre Prospective Study
Siyuan Fan, Xiaojuan Wang, … Hongzhi Guan·bioRxiv·Jun 10, 2019
- Enhanced virus detection and metagenomic sequencing in patients with meningitis and encephalitis
Anne L Piantadosi, Shibani S. Mukerji, … Pardis Christine Sabeti·mBioPeer-reviewed·Aug 31, 2021
- Next-generation sequencing in neuropathological diagnosis of infections of the nervous system
Steven L. Salzberg, Florian Breitwieser, … Carlos A. Pardo·bioRxiv·Feb 9, 2016
- Next-Generation Sequencing Could be a Promising Diagnostic Approach for Pathogen Detection: Pathogenic Analysis of Pediatric Bacterial Meningitis by Next-Generation Sequencing Technology Directly from Cerebrospinal Fluid Specimens
Ling-yun Guo, Yong-jun Li, … Gang Liu·bioRxiv·Jun 6, 2018