Sequestration of histidine kinases by non-cognate response regulators establishes a threshold level of stimulation for bacterial two-component signaling

Two-component signaling systems (TCSs) in bacteria are often positively auto-regulated, where the histidine kinase (HK) and response regulator (RR) proteins comprising a TCS are expressed downstream of the signal they transduce. This auto-regulation improves the sensitivity of the TCS to stimuli and amplifies adaptive responses. The downside, however, is that the TCS may mount disproportionately large responses to weak or fleeting signals. How bacteria prevent such disproportionate responses is not known. Here, we show that sequestration of phosphorylated HKs by non-cognate RRs serves as a design to prevent such disproportionate responses. Using TCSs of M. tuberculosis as model systems, we found that with every one of the five HKs we studied, there was at least one non-cognate RR with higher affinity than that of the cognate RR for the HK. Phosphorylated HKs would thus preferentially bind the non-cognate RRs, suppressing signal transduction through the cognate pathways, which we demonstrated in vitro. Using mathematical modeling of TCS signaling in vivo, we predicted that this sequestration would introduce a threshold level of stimulation for a significant response, preventing responses to signals below this threshold. Finally, we showed in vivo using tunable expression systems in M. bovis that upregulation of a higher affinity non-cognate RR substantially suppressed the output from the cognate TCS pathway, presenting strong evidence of sequestration by non-cognate RRs as a design to regulate TCS signaling. Blocking this sequestration may be a novel intervention strategy, as it would compromise bacterial fitness by letting it respond unnecessarily to signals.