The contributions of DNA accessibility and transcription factor occupancy to enhancer activity during cellular differentiation

Abstract

The upregulation of gene expression by enhancers depends upon the interplay between the binding of sequence-specific transcription factors (TFs) and DNA accessibility. DNA accessibility is thought to limit the ability of TFs to bind to their sites, while TFs can increase accessibility to recruit additional factors that upregulate gene expression. Given this interplay, the causative regulatory events underlying the modulation of gene expression during cellular differentiation remain unknown for the vast majority of genes. We investigated the binding-site resolution dynamics of DNA accessibility and the expression dynamics of the enhancers of an important neutrophil gene, Cebpa, during macrophage-neutrophil differentiation. Reporter genes were integrated in a site-specific manner in PUER cells, which are progenitors that can be differentiated into neutrophils or macrophages in vitro by activating the pan-leukocyte TF PU.1. Time series data show that two enhancers upregulate reporter expression during the first 48 hours of neutrophil differentiation. Surprisingly, there is little or no increase in the total accessibility, measured by ATAC-Seq, of the enhancers during the same time period. Conversely, total accessibility peaks 96 hrs after PU.1 activation--consistent with its role as a pioneer--but the enhancers do not upregulate gene expression. Combining deeply sequenced ATAC-Seq data with a new bias-correction method allowed the profiling of acces-sibility at single-nucleotide resolution and revealed protected regions in the enhancers that match all previously characterized TF binding sites and ChIP-Seq data. Although the accessibility of most positions does not change during early differentiation, that of positions neighboring TF binding sites, an indicator of TF occupancy, did in-crease significantly. The localized accessibility changes are limited to nucleotides neighboring C/EBP-family TF binding sites, showing that the upregulation of enhancer activity during early differentiation is driven by C/EBP-family TF binding. These results show that increasing the total accessibility of enhancers is not sufficient for upregulating their activity and other events such as TF binding are necessary for upregulation. Also, TF binding can cause upregulation without a perceptible increase in total accessibility. Finally, this study demonstrates the feasibility of comprehensively mapping individual TF binding sites as footprints using high coverage ATAC-Seq and inferring the sequence of events in gene regulation by combining with time-series gene expression data.