Mass Cytometry Study on the Heterogeneity in Cellular Association and Cytotoxicity of Silver Nanoparticles in Human Immune Cells

There have been many reports about the adverse effects of nanoparticles (NPs) on the environment and human health. Conventional toxicity assessments of NPs frequently assume uniform distribution of monodisperse NPs in homogeneous cell populations, and provide information on the relationships between the administered dose of NPs and cellular responses averaged for a large number of cells. They may have limitations in describing the wide heterogeneity of cell-NP interactions, caused by cell-to-cell and NP-to-NP variances. To achieve more detailed insight into the heterogeneity of cell-NP interactions, it is essential to understand the cellular association and adverse effects of NPs at single-cell level. In this study, we applied mass cytometry to investigate the interactions between silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) and primary human immune cells. High dimensionality of mass cytometry allowed us to identify various immune cell types and observe the cellular association and toxicity of AgNPs in each population. Our findings showed that AgNPs had higher affinity with phagocytic cells like monocytes and dendritic cells and caused more severe toxic effects than with T cells, B cells and NK cells. Multi-element detection capability of mass cytometry also enabled us to simultaneously monitor cellular AgNP dose and intracellular signaling of individual cells, and subsequently investigate the dose-response relationships of each immune population at single-cell level, which are often hidden in conventional toxicity assays at bulk-cell level. Our study will assist future development of single-cell dose-response models for various NPs and will provide key information for the safe use of nanomaterials for biomedical applications.