Sign in
Developmental BiologyDevelopmental Cell
Peer-reviewed journal article

Single-cell analysis of shared signatures and transcriptional diversity during zebrafish development

Abhinav SuriD, Yiqun WangiD, Paulina CapariD, Gennady Margolin, Morgan Kathleen ProchaskaiD, Jeffrey A. FarrelliD

Abstract

During development, animals generate distinct cell populations with specific identities, functions, and morphologies. We mapped transcriptionally distinct populations across 489,686 cells from 62 stages during wild-type zebrafish embryogenesis and early larval development (3-120 hours post-fertilization). Using these data, we identified the limited catalog of gene expression programs reused across multiple tissues and their cell-type-specific adaptations. We also determined the duration each transcriptional state is present during development and suggest new long-term cycling populations. Focused analyses of non-skeletal muscle and the endoderm identified transcriptional profiles of understudied cell types and subpopulations, including the pneumatic duct, individual intestinal smooth muscle layers, spatially distinct pericyte subpopulations, and homologs of recently discovered human best4+ enterocytes. The transcriptional regulators of these populations remain unknown, so we reconstructed gene expression trajectories to suggest candidates. To enable additional discoveries, we make this comprehensive transcriptional atlas of early zebrafish development available through our website, Daniocell.

02 /Specification & Classification

Click any tag to browse matching papers

In-depth summary

✦ Multi-agent verified full-text synthesis

Claude Opus 5.5 · xhigh effort · 8 Nov 2026 · from the full text of version 3 (15 Apr 2023) · CC0 1.0

A 489,686-cell scRNA-seq atlas of 62 zebrafish stages (3.3–120 hpf) identifies 90 multi-tissue gene programs and markers for pericyte subtypes, intestinal smooth muscle layers, and best4+ enterocytes.

Single-cell RNA-seq timecourses can expose overlooked cell types and order gene expression cascades, but earlier wild-type zebrafish atlases used single nuclei, covered shorter windows, or sampled stages less often. Sampling every 2 hours (deeply every 12 hours) from 14 to 120 hpf, merged with earlier embryo data, enables whole-transcriptome comparisons across tissues and stages plus molecular handles for poorly characterized tissues.

Key results

  1. ShownThe atlas resolves roughly 300 cell types or states and gives temporally resolved expression for two-thirds of annotated genes, most of which vary across cell types or stages rather than being ubiquitous.

    489,686 cells from 62 stages in 19 tissues and 521 clusters; 24,216 of 36,250 genes (67%) detected; ~3.6% ubiquitous with low fluctuation (logCV ≤ –0.85), ~18% cell-type specific (≤25 clusters), 78% variable across many tissues; computationally predicted and XLOC genes detected at 28% and 37%. · Temporally dense sampling of zebrafish…; Spatiotemporal variation of gene expression…; Remapping and integration of 2018 Drop-seq data

  2. ShownOnly a limited catalog of expression programs is reused across tissues, and shared cores are usually customized per cell type (e.g., a Megalin-linked reabsorption program in gut LREs and pronephros, a pan-epithelial program, a mucin O-glycosylation program).

    Mfuzz on kNN-smoothed data: 200 modules requested, 147 retained after QC, 90 shared across tissues (8–735 member genes, mean 95); 82 annotated (20 ubiquitous, 62 restricted to cell types in 2 or more tissues); GEP-193 split megalin paralogs lrp2a (pronephros) and lrp2b (intestine); GEP-106 spanned all epithelia incl. lens, liver, RPE. · Identification of shared developmental gene…; Gene module identification

  3. ShownMost whole-transcriptome states persist for at most 36 hours; long-term states are mostly non-cycling late cells, while long-term cycling states include known stem cells and a few uncharacterized candidate progenitor populations.

    ε-neighborhood (ε = 35) stage differences: 18% of cells in states lasting ≤12 h, 58% ≤24 h, 81% ≤36 h, 93% ≤48 h, 7% >48 h; of long-term (≥36 h) cells, 68% non-cycling (74% of these at 72 hpf or older) and 32% cycling, including radial glia, satellite cells, HSCs plus oit3+/lyve1a+ lymphatic cells and myoseptal fibroblasts. · Mapping the duration of transcriptional states…; Identifying short-term and long-term…

  4. ShownFocused non-skeletal muscle analysis reveals three zebrafish pericyte subpopulations, one (epas1a+) spatially restricted to hindbrain vessels, and distinct molecular profiles for circular versus longitudinal intestinal smooth muscle layers.

    3,866 cells yielded three pericyte clusters (C4, C9, C20); HCR placed epas1a+/ndufa4l2a+ pericyte-2 cells at the hindbrain posterior cerebral vein, almost none in forebrain, eye or arches; 5000 simulated doublet pairs per group failed to recreate subtype signatures; in situ mapped C8 (kcnk18, fsta) to inner circular, C10 (il13ra2) to outer longitudinal SMCs. · Focused analysis of zebrafish non-skeletal…; Molecular characterization of zebrafish…; Simulation of artificial pericyte doublets

  5. ShownEndoderm sub-clustering yields the first specific markers for the pneumatic duct and identifies zebrafish homologs of human best4+ enterocytes, with URD trajectories nominating candidate progenitors and transcriptional regulators.

    12,592 endodermal cells in 33 clusters; C32 (arising 2–3 dpf) specifically expresses sftpba and sim1b, confirmed by in situ in pneumatic duct and anterior swim bladder bud; best4+ cells (first seen 3 dpf) share best4, otop2, cftr, notch2 with human counterparts; branchpoint progenitors express atoh1b, ascl1a, tnfrsf11a, followed by dacha and pbx3a. · Focused analysis of endodermal development…; Comparison of gene expression between species

Methods, data and reproducibility

MULTI-seq-hashed 10X Chromium scRNA-seq of whole wild-type embryos and larvae at 50 stages (14–120 hpf), merged with remapped Drop-seq data (3.3–12 hpf), followed by iterative Leiden clustering, ε-neighborhood state-duration analysis, Mfuzz gene programs, URD trajectories, and HCR or fluorescent in situ validation.

  • New whole-animal scRNA-seq (10X v3.1, MULTI-seq hashed) of wild-type TL/AB embryos and larvae spanning 14–120 hpf · zebrafish · n = 50 stages · GSE223922 (NCBI GEO)
  • Published Drop-seq embryo data (Farrell et al. 2018), 3.3–12 hpf, remapped to the same reference · zebrafish
  • Integrated developmental atlas (19 tissues, 521 clusters) · zebrafish · n = 489,686 cells; 62 stages
  • Non-skeletal muscle subset (smooth muscle, pericytes, myofibroblasts, related populations) · zebrafish · n = 3,866 cells
  • Endodermal derivative subset · zebrafish · n = 12,592 cells; 33 clusters
  • Human colon and small intestine scRNA-seq datasets used for best4+ enterocyte cross-species comparison · human
  • Fixed 3–5 dpf larvae (including flk::mCherry-CAAX and flk::GFP lines) for HCR and fluorescent in situ hybridization · zebrafish
Methods & tools
10X Genomics Chromium Single Cell 3' v3.1, MULTI-seq cell hashing (deMULTIplex), Cell Ranger 4.0.0 with STAR 2.5.1b, Seurat (v3.1.5 and v4.1.0), Drop-seq Tools 1.12 and Picard Tools, Lawson Lab Zebrafish Transcriptome Annotation v4.3.2 on GRCz11, Mfuzz fuzzy c-means clustering, kNN smoothing (Wagner, Yan, Yanai approach), URD v1.1.2 (destiny diffusion maps), biomaRt for zebrafish-human orthologs, Hybridization chain reaction (HCR) with Özpolat lab probe generator, ZFIN gene expression database
Reagents & environment
Cell Ranger 4.0.0 (STAR 2.5.1b); STAR 2.5.4a and Drop-seq Tools 1.12 for remapping; Seurat 3.1.5 (R 3.6.3) and Seurat 4.1.0; URD v1.1.2; GRCz11 release 99 with Lawson annotation v4.3.2
Reproducibility gaps
The authors' analysis code (GitHub, farrelllab/2023_Sur) is described as forthcoming ('will be available') rather than released at posting; no hardware or runtime details are reported.
Limitations (6)
  • Duration analysis cannot flag long-term states that emerge in the final 36 hours (84–120 hpf) because sampling stops at 120 hpf, and dividing progenitors resembling differentiated progeny (e.g., erythroblasts, periderm) inflate apparent duration. · stated by the authors
  • Thresholds for calling genes detected and for CV-based expression categories involve some arbitrariness, and the reported transcriptional state durations depend on the similarity threshold chosen for the analysis. · stated by the authors
  • No swim bladder cluster was recovered, suggesting that tissue dissociated poorly; small tissue chunks often remained because pushing for complete digestion markedly reduced cell viability. · stated by the authors
  • Low best4+ enterocyte numbers prevented sub-clustering, and 8 of the 90 shared programs could not be annotated and may be technical artifacts. · stated by the authors
  • Whether pericyte subtypes are stable identities or transient location-dependent states requires long-term imaging, and functions of subtype genes and candidate regulators still need reverse genetic testing. · stated by the authors
  • Candidate regulators (e.g., pbx3a, foxq1a, sim1b) and putative stem-cell populations rest on co-expression and URD pseudotime without perturbation, and the heavily hand-curated 521-cluster annotation may be hard to reproduce independently. · noted in this summary

Who should read:Read this if you need a dense zebrafish developmental scRNA-seq reference, or study pericyte heterogeneity, intestinal smooth muscle layers, the pneumatic duct, best4+ enterocytes, or gene programs shared across tissues.

Reproducibility ledger

Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.

Sign in to file a reproducibility report.