Conserved TIR-only proteins drive transcriptional defense and basal immunity in dicot and monocot plants

Toll/interleukin-1/resistance (TIR) domain NADase enzymes signal in plant immunity by producing ribosylated nucleotide second messengers which activate EDS1 dimer-helper NLR pathways to restrict pathogen growth. Members of a small, distinctive group of TIR-only proteins are conserved between dicots and monocots, yet their functions remain poorly understood. Here, we show that conserved TIR-only proteins in Arabidopsis and barley share a fundamental enzymatic role in promoting basal defense against virulent filamentous pathogens, independently of NLR mediated effector-triggered immunity. Metabolite analysis of transiently expressed Arabidopsis and barley TIR-only proteins revealed their capacity to produce ribosylated cyclic nucleotides in vivo. By comparing phenotypes of tir-only and eds1 pad4 CRISPR mutants in the two species, as well as adr1 mutants in barley, we established that the TIR-only proteins promote PAMP-triggered transcriptional defenses associated with pathogen restriction. Barley possesses just one essential TIR-only enzyme and mutations of the two conserved TIR-only members in Arabidopsis were not compensated for by numerous other TIR-domain genes in the basal immune response. These findings suggest that conserved TIR-only proteins make a crucial contribution to TIR basal defense signaling networks of Arabidopsis and barley. We propose that a shared function in transcriptional defense regulation could explain the evolutionary retention of this discrete TIR-only group across monocot and dicot lineages.