Asymmetric Allostery in Estrogen Receptor-α Homodimers Drives Responses to the Ensemble of Estrogens in the Hormonal Milieu

Abstract

The estrogen receptor- (ER) is thought to function only as a homodimer, but responds to a variety of environmental, metazoan, and therapeutic estrogens at sub-saturating doses, supporting binding mixtures of ligands as well as dimers that are only partially occupied. Here, we present a series of flexible ER ligands that bind to receptor dimers with individual ligand poses favoring distinct receptor conformations --receptor conformational heterodimers--mimicking the binding of two different ligands. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that the pairs of different ligand poses changed the correlated motion across the dimer interface to generate asymmetric communication between the dimer interface, the ligands, and the surface binding sites for epigenetic regulatory proteins. By examining binding of the same ligand in crystal structures of ER in the agonist versus antagonist conformers, we also showed that these allosteric signals are bidirectional. The receptor conformer can drive different ligand binding modes to support agonist versus antagonist activity profiles, a revision of ligand binding theory that has focused on unidirectional signaling from ligand to the coregulator binding site. We also observed differences in the allosteric signals between ligand and coregulator binding sites in the monomeric versus dimeric receptor, and when bound by two different ligands, states that are physiologically relevant. Thus, ER conformational heterodimers integrate two different ligand-regulated activity profiles, representing new modes for ligand-dependent regulation of ER activity. SignificanceThe estrogen receptor- (ER) regulates transcription in response to a hormonal milieu that includes low levels of estradiol, a variety of environmental estrogens, as well as ER antagonists such as breast cancer anti-hormonal therapies. While ER has been studied as a homodimer, the variety of ligand and receptor concentrations in different tissues means that the receptor can be occupied with two different ligands, with only one ligand in the dimer, or as a monomer. Here, we use X-ray crystallography and molecular dynamics simulations to reveal a new mode for ligand regulation of ER activity whereby sequence-identical homodimers can act as functional or conformational heterodimers having unique signaling characteristics, with ligand-selective allostery operating across the dimer interface integrating two different signaling outcomes.