Gastruloids develop the three body axes in the absence of extraembryonic tissues and spatially localised signalling
David A. TurneriD, M. Girgin, Luz Alonso‐Crisostomo, Vikas TrivediiD, Peter Baillie‐JohnsoniD, C. R. Glodowski, Penny Hayward, Jérôme CollignoniD, Carsten R. Gustavsen, Palle SerupiD, Benjamin SteventoniD, Matthias P. LütolfiD, Arias A. Martinez
Abstract
Establishment of the three body axes is a critical step during animal development. In mammals, genetic studies have shown that a combination of precisely deployed signals from extraembryonic tissues position the anteroposterior axis (AP) within the embryo and lead to the emergence of the dorsoventral (DV) and left-right (LR) axes. We have used Gastruloids, embryonic organoids, as a model system to understand this process and find that they are able to develop AP, DV and LR axes as well as to undergo axial elongation in a manner that mirror embryos. The Gastruloids can be grown for 160 hours and form derivatives from ectoderm, mesoderm and endoderm. We focus on the AP axis and show that in the Gastruloids this axis is registered in the expression of T/Bra at one pole that corresponds to the tip of the elongation. We find that localisation of T/Bra expression depends on the combined activities of Wnt/{beta}-Catenin and Nodal/Smad2,3 signalling, and that BMP signalling is dispensable for this process. Furthermore, AP axis specification occurs in the absence of both extraembryonic tissues and of localised sources of signalling. Our experiments show that Nodal, together with Wnt/{beta}-Catenin signalling, is essential for the expression of T/Bra but that Wnt signalling has a separable activity in the elongation of the axis. The results lead us to suggest that, in the embryo, the role of the extraembryonic tissues might not be to induce the axes but to bias an intrinsic ability of the embryo to break its initial symmetry and organise its axes.\n\nOne sentence summaryCulture of aggregates of defined number of Embryonic Stem cells leads to self-organised embryo-like structures which, in the absence of localised signalling from extra embryonic tissues and under the autonomous influence of Wnt and Nodal signalling, develop the three main axes of the body.
02 /Specification & Classification
Click any tag to browse matching papers- Citations
- 273
- FWCI
- 8.26
- Field percentile
- top 1%
- Organism
- Assay
- Research Focus
- Approach
In-depth summary
Claude Opus 5.5 · xhigh effort · 8 Nov 2026 · from the full text of version 1 (31 Jan 2017) · CC BY 4.0
Mouse embryonic stem cell aggregates (Gastruloids) form anteroposterior, dorsoventral and left-right axes without extraembryonic tissue or localised signals, through Nodal-initiated, Wnt-stabilised T/Brachyury polarisation.
In mammals, axis formation is thought to rely on symmetry-breaking cues from extraembryonic tissues, and genetic loss-of-function studies struggle to separate correlation from causation. Gastruloids give a minimal, build-up system showing that axes can arise intrinsically, which suggests extraembryonic signals bias, rather than induce, symmetry breaking in the embryo.
Key results
ShownAfter a 48-72h pulse of the Wnt agonist CHI99201 (Chi), 120h Gastruloids show a posterior T/Bra and Cdx2 tip and an orthogonal dorsoventral-like axis. Lateral Smad2,3 reporter asymmetry hints at a left-right axis and a node-like region.
Immunostaining and reporters at 120h after aggregation (AA): T/Bra and Cdx2 at the tip with a shallow TLC2 Wnt gradient; Sox1::GFP and Sox2 neural tissue on one side, clustered Nodal::YFP opposite; Smad2,3 activity turns bilaterally asymmetric over time. Shaken cultures reach 160h AA, exceed 1mm and contain a Sox17-high, Sox2-low tube. · 2.1 Axial organisation in Gastruloids; Figure legends
ShownGastruloids are built only from embryonic, epiblast-like cells. They lack extraembryonic gene expression, BMP signalling and early GATA6, so their axes form without extraembryonic tissue; 48h and 72h AA approximate E6.0 and E7.0.
qRT-PCR (~64 Gastruloids per time-point) at 48h AA detects Fgf4, Fgf5, Axin2, Wnt3, Nodal, Cripto and low Lefty1, but not BMP4, Dkk, Furin, Lrp2 or Dab, with very low Cerberus; the Smad1,5,7 BMP reporter is silent under Chi yet responds to exogenous BMP; GATA6::H2B-Venus is absent for the first 72h, appearing at ~88h. · 2.3 Extraembryonic tissues are not required for…; 5.4 Quantitative RT-PCR; Figure legends
ShownT/Bra polarises spontaneously in neutral N2B27 medium. A Wnt/beta-catenin pulse (Chi or Wnt3a) during 48-72h amplifies, sharpens and stabilises this pole and drives elongation, and the timing of exposure is critical.
T/Bra::GFP is weak and partly biased at 24h AA and more polarised at 48h; Chi or Wnt3a at 48-72h gives tighter fluorescence distributions than DMSO, and Hu Moment PCA separates elongated Chi/Wnt3a Gastruloids from spherical controls on PC1. Chi at 24-72h yields multiple T/Bra foci, whereas exposure at 48-96h tends to abolish polarisation and elongation. · 2.2 Wnt/β-catpole of expression is less…; 2.6 Wnt/β-catenin can generate multiple axes in…; Figure legends
ShownNodal/ALK4 signalling is required to start T/Bra expression, whereas raised Nodal after 48h AA restrains elongation, so T/Bra induction and axial extension can be uncoupled.
SB431542 (SB43) at 48-72h abolishes T/Bra::GFP and elongation (Gastruloids stay spherical), and Chi co-treatment does not rescue it; SB43 at 24-48h before Chi delays and destabilises T/Bra but leaves elongation intact or enhanced; Nodal at 48-72h, alone or with Chi, raises T/Bra yet leaves Gastruloids spheroid or ovoid. · 2.4 Nodal signalling promotes T / Bra expression; Figure legends
ShownSpatially uniform Nodal rescues symmetry breaking in Nodal-null Gastruloids, so a localised Nodal source is not needed for AP polarisation, provided Nodal is supplied before the Wnt pulse.
Nodal^(-/-) Gastruloids stay spherical or ovoid and ~90% form small bulbous protrusions by 120h AA; Chi (48-72h) alone raises elongation to ~50% but fails to upregulate T/Bra and Cdx2; 100 ng/ml Nodal at 24-48h before Chi restores T/Bra and Cdx2 patterning and lifts the elongated, protrusion-free class (0 to 50%); later Nodal windows are less effective. · 2.7 A polarised source of Nodal signalling is…; Figure legends
Methods, data and reproducibility
Defined numbers of mouse ESCs (~300 cells, line-dependent) are aggregated in N2B27 in low-adhesion 96-well plates and given timed agonist or antagonist pulses, mostly 24h long with some longer windows. Outcomes are read out by reporter live imaging, immunofluorescence, qRT-PCR, posterior-to-anterior fluorescence profiles and Hu Moment shape PCA.
- T/Bra::GFP reporter mESC Gastruloids under timed Chi, Wnt3a, Nodal, SB43, Dkk1, IWP3 and XAV939 regimes (fluorescence profiles, live imaging) · mouse
- Sox1::GFP, Sox1/eGFP Bra/mCherry (SBR) and Sox17::GFP reporter Gastruloids for neural, axial and endoderm marker imaging · mouse
- Signalling reporter lines: TCF/LEF::mCherry (TLC2, Wnt), AR8::mCherry (Smad2,3), Nodal::YFP, IBRE4-TA-Cerulean (Smad1,5,7), GATA6::H2B-Venus · mouse
- Nodal^(-/-) mutant mESC Gastruloids given timed recombinant Nodal and Chi pulses (morphology, protrusion counts, T/Bra and Cdx2 immunostaining) · mouse
- qRT-PCR of T/Bra::GFP Gastruloids after a DMSO or Chi pulse, harvested at 48 or 72h AA · mouse · n = ~64 Gastruloids per time-point
- Confocal z-stacks of fixed, immunostained Gastruloids · mouse · n = at least 4 Gastruloids per condition
- Long-term shaken Gastruloid cultures fixed at 160h AA · mouse
- Methods & tools
- Gastruloid culture (non-adherent mouse ESC aggregates in N2B27), CHI99201 (Chi), recombinant Wnt3a and Nodal, Inhibitors: SB431542, IWP3, XAV939, Dkk1, Confocal microscopy (Zeiss LSM700) and widefield live imaging (Zeiss AxioObserver.Z1), Zen2010 v6; Velocity, FIJI/ImageJ (line-of-interest profiles, Pairwise Stitching plugin), Hu Moments shape descriptors with principal component analysis, Jupyter IPython: Matplotlib, NumPy, SciPy, tifffile, Statsmodels, Pandas, qRT-PCR (RNeasy Mini kit, PPIA normalisation), Mann-Whitney U test with Bonferroni adjustment, Moxi Z automated cell counter
- Reagents & environment
- Analysis in Jupyter IPython notebooks (Matplotlib, NumPy, SciPy, tifffile, Statsmodels, Pandas; versions not stated); image capture in Zen2010 v6, visualisation in Velocity, image analysis in FIJI.
- Reproducibility gaps
- Analysis code is stated to be available only on request; no repository URL or data accession is given, and cell numbers, antibodies, reagent concentrations and primers appear only in supplementary tables.
Limitations (5)
- No anterior head or brain structures form. The authors attribute this to strong early Wnt exposure and the lack of a prechordal plate, implying that extraembryonic signals may still be needed to position the brain. · stated by the authors
- Results varied between replicate experiments: variation was large for Chi plus SB43 co-treatment and present to some degree for the timing of Nodal rescue in Nodal mutants. The fraction of T/Bra-expressing Gastruloids at 24h also differed between experiments. · stated by the authors
- Sox17::GFP fluorescence in fig. S3 cannot be compared quantitatively across replicates because exposure times and objectives differed, and the Wnt3a T/Bra::GFP traces in Fig. 3B come from a different experiment than the DMSO and Chi traces. · stated by the authors
- The left-right axis and node-like region are inferred from weak Smad2,3 and Nodal::YFP reporter asymmetries described only qualitatively (a large proportion, a low frequency), with no counts and no dedicated left-right marker genes analysed. · noted in this summary
- Some supporting data are not shown (inhibitor suppression of reporters, early Nodal::YFP pattern) or are deferred to a manuscript in preparation, and qRT-PCR uses pooled Gastruloids without reported replicates or statistics. · noted in this summary
Who should read:Read this if you study mammalian axis formation or stem-cell embryo models and want perturbation evidence on how Nodal and Wnt timing, rather than localised sources, polarise T/Brachyury.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- Interactions between Nodal and Wnt signalling Drive Robust Symmetry Breaking and Axial Organisation in Gastruloids (Embryonic Organoids)
D.A. Turner, C.R. Glodowski, … A. Martinez Arias·bioRxiv·May 13, 2016
- Dynamics of anteroposterior axis establishment in a mammalian embryo-like system
Kerim Anlaş, Nicola Gritti, … Vikas Trivedi·bioRxiv·Feb 24, 2021
- Axial patterning of gastruloids via diverse cell type compositions
Kerim Anlaş, Fumio Nakaki, … Vikas Trivedi·bioRxiv·Mar 26, 2025
- Gastruloids generated without exogenous Wnt activation develop anterior neural tissues
Mehmet Girgin, Nicolas Broguière, … Matthias P. Lütolf·Stem Cell ReportsPeer-reviewed·Apr 22, 2021
- Morphogenetic constrains in the development of gastruloids: implications for mouse gastrulation
Ulla-Maj Fiúza, Sara Bonavia, … Alfonso Martínez Arias·bioRxiv·Dec 12, 2024
- Reorientation of the primary body axis by ectopic embryonic cWnt signaling.
Naveen M. Wijesena, Mark Q. Martindale·bioRxiv·Nov 17, 2017