Synovial transcriptional clusters link cartilage degeneration to cell-type-specific gene expression in knee osteoarthritis

Abstract

ObjectivesTo identify synovial transcriptional clusters in human knee osteoarthritis (OA) and determine how these relate to synovial histologic features, cell-type-associated gene expression, and cartilage degeneration severity. MethodsBulk RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) of synovial tissue from n = 135 patients with knee OA was analyzed using consensus clustering. Clusters were compared by clinical and histologic features, including cartilage degeneration severity (OARSI score). Single-cell RNA-seq (n = 18) and spatial transcriptomics were used to relate cartilage degeneration-associated gene expression patterns to synovial cell populations. ResultsFour synovial transcriptional clusters that differed in synovial histologic features and cartilage degeneration severity were identified. Greater cartilage degeneration was associated with enrichment of lining fibroblast- and inflammatory myeloid-associated gene expression, whereas lesser cartilage degeneration was associated with enrichment of sublining fibroblast, endothelial, mural cell, and adipocyte-associated gene expression. ConclusionsHuman knee OA synovium segregates into transcriptional clusters associated with cartilage degeneration severity. Synovial transcriptional heterogeneity corresponds to cell-type-associated gene expression. Key messagesO_ST_ABSWhat is already known on this topicC_ST_ABSO_LIOsteoarthritis synovium exhibits marked histologic and molecular heterogeneity. C_LIO_LISynovial inflammation detected by MRI correlates with cartilage degeneration and predicts progressive cartilage loss in knee OA. C_LIO_LIPrior transcriptomic studies have identified molecular subsets of OA synovium, but their relationship to cartilage degeneration severity remains unclear. C_LI What this study addsO_LIOA synovium segregates into four transcriptional clusters: Sublining (C1), Lymphomyeloid (C2), Myeloid (C3), and Major trauma (C4). C_LIO_LIGreater cartilage degeneration is associated with enrichment of inflammatory myeloid and lining fibroblast gene expression, whereas lesser degeneration is associated with enrichment of adipocyte, sublining fibroblast, endothelial, and mural cell-associated gene expression. C_LI How this study might affect research, practice or policyO_LIProvides a framework for a clinically relevant biological stratification of OA patients based on synovial molecular features. C_LIO_LIInforms future efforts to link synovial biology with OA prognosis, cartilage degeneration, treatment allocation, and development of targeted therapeutic strategies. C_LI