DNA end-resection in highly accessible chromatin produces a toxic break
J. van den Berg, S. E. P. Joosten, Y. Kim, A. G. Manjon, L. Krenning, L. Koob, F. M. Feringa, R. Klompmaker, B. van den Broek, K. Jalink, W. Zwart, R. H. Medema
Abstract
The authors have withdrawn their manuscript whilst they perform additional experiments to test some of their conclusions further. Despite repetitive attempts to reproduce the data shown in figure 2I, we have failed to obtain convincing evidence that chemical inhibition of Mre11 can improve the fitness of cells exposed to the so-called "halt" breaks. Upon re-analysis of the raw data used to compose figure 2I, we noted inconsistencies in the inclusion of datapoints, for which a satisfactory motivation was not apparent. In order to reproduce the experiments with the DNA-PK inhibitor, we ordered new batches of this compound, but noticed that the IC50 was significantly lower than that of the earlier batch (as determined in suppl. fig.1). While this might be due to a difference in batches, the IC50 of the newer batches was more comparable to the IC50 of this compound described for other cell lines. This sheds doubts on the quality of the batch used for the experiments shown in our manuscript, and we no longer wish to draw any conclusions based on these experiments. The authors hope that future experiments can resolve if open chromatin does indeed produce a potentially more toxic DNA break. The authors do not wish this work to be cited as reference for the project. If you have any questions, please contact the corresponding author.
Reproducibility ledger
Nobody has reported trying to reproduce this paper yet. Did you replicate an experiment or run the code? Your report saves the next lab a week.
Sign in to file a reproducibility report.
Related papers
- DNA-PK Promotes DNA End Resection at DNA Double Strand Breaks in G0 cells
Faith C. Fowler, Bo-Ruei Chen, … Jessica K. Tyler·eLifePeer-reviewed·May 9, 2022
- Persistent broken chromosome inheritance drives genome instability
Chen‐Chun Pai, Samuel C. Durley, … Timothy C. Humphrey·bioRxiv·Aug 26, 2020
- Hyperactive end joining repair mediates resistance to DNA damaging therapy in p53-deficient cells
R. J. Kumar, H. X. Chao, … G. P. Gupta·bioRxiv·Apr 1, 2020
- DNA-dependent protein kinase promotes DNA end processing by MRN and CtIP
Rajashree A. Deshpande, Logan R. Myler, … Tanya T. Paull·Science AdvancesPeer-reviewed·Jan 8, 2020
- Rev7 and 53BP1/Crb2 prevent RecQ helicase-dependent hyper-resection of DNA double-strand breaks
Bryan A. Leland, Angela C. Chen, … Megan C. King·eLifePeer-reviewed·Apr 26, 2018
- Single-cell resolution of resection-dependent chromatin accessibility in response to DNA double-strand breaks reveals specific gene expression programs
Sarah Collins, Anne-Laure Finoux, … Thomas Clouaire·bioRxiv·Apr 23, 2026